TL;DR Key takeaways
- Read the customer and upstream agreements together: using an external conversion provider does not by itself establish your role or transfer every customer obligation.
- Compare the calculation base and your own costs, not just the advertised share. Keep earned income, retained contribution and cash received separate.
- Extra control can justify lower direct FX income only if the agreement grants it, its wider benefit is credible and your team can manage the obligations.
An FX offer can double your advertised revenue share and still leave you with less income. It can also move execution to an external provider without transferring your obligations to the customer.
Comparing FX partnership models means looking past both the percentage and the promise of outsourced execution. The commercial question is whether the income and useful control you keep justify the work and exposure you take on.
Separate the customer relationship from the execution role
Referral, agent and principal are not three rungs on a ladder of increasing profitability. A referral describes introducing a customer. Agent and principal describe capacities in executing transactions. A referral agreement may govern your reward for an introduction, while separate service and dealing agreements determine who provides the conversion and on what terms.
The December 2024 FX Global Code provides a useful distinction for principal vs agent trading. It is a voluntary wholesale-FX good-practice framework, not a universal legal classification for every payments or retail arrangement:
- An agent executes under the client's mandate without taking market risk on that order.
- A principal transacts on its own behalf, taking risks that can include credit risk and varying degrees of market risk.
Those capacities can be agreed through standing terms or trade by trade. Neither the branding of the customer journey nor the use of an external conversion provider establishes the role by itself.
For a payment provider, there are two relationships to examine: your agreement with the customer and your agreement with the upstream FX provider. Your business can be the upstream provider's client while acting as principal towards its own customer. Read the agreements together to establish who contracts with the customer, who executes the conversion, who is the counterparty and where transaction exposure sits. Outsourcing execution does not answer all four questions.
Follow the percentage through to retained income
Now consider two hypothetical offers. Assume the same €10 million of monthly conversion volume generates €20,000 in customer charges under either arrangement. The figures below are illustrative, not market pricing or forecasts.
- Offer A: referral. Your FX referral commission is 30% of those customer charges, giving you €6,000. Assume your monthly costs for servicing the referral arrangement are €1,000. You retain €5,000.
- Offer B: customer-facing conversion. Your share is 60%, but it applies after €8,000 of specified provider costs are deducted. The calculation base is therefore €12,000, and your contractual share is €7,200. Assume your own support, reconciliation and conversion-operations costs are €4,000. You retain €3,200.
The second offer advertises twice the share and produces €1,200 more contractual income. Yet it leaves the business with €1,800 less retained income each month. The additional work costs more than the additional income it brings. The cost difference is an assumption about these offers, not an inherent rule about referral and execution arrangements.
Here, retained income means the contractual amount earned less the business's relevant operating costs. It is a contribution comparison, before general overhead, tax and any additional funding costs or losses—not a claim about net profit.
The decisive contract term is the revenue-share calculation base: which receipts count, which deductions come first and which adjustments can change the result. A share of customer fees, a share of collected fees and a share of margin after specified costs are different propositions. The same discipline applies to a quoted spread: it is not the retained margin if upstream conversion costs and your own delivery costs still have to come out.
For finance, this means asking for enough contractual and reporting detail to reproduce the calculation. A percentage is difficult to value if the underlying deductions are unclear.
Earned income is not necessarily available cash
Payment conditions create another distinction. If remuneration depends on fee collection, a minimum payout threshold or submission of an invoice, an amount calculated for the month may not yet be available to fund that month's costs.
Keep the amount earned, the amount retained after your costs and the amount actually paid as separate figures. An attractive contribution can still require working capital if your business pays its staff and suppliers before the partnership pays you. That timing belongs in the comparison, rather than being treated as an administrative detail after signing.
What would make the extra responsibility worthwhile?
In the hypothetical example, the customer-facing arrangement needs another €1,800 a month of retained contribution just to match the referral offer, before allowing for any additional exposure. That gap gives the commercial discussion a concrete starting point.
Perhaps keeping conversion within your payment workflow supports the wider customer relationship. Perhaps authority over customer pricing gives you a way to improve the economics. Those can be valid reasons to accept lower direct FX income—but only if the agreement grants the relevant control and the wider benefit is credible. A branded customer journey does not necessarily confer authority over pricing or execution.
The responsibilities need equal attention. Under the Code's framework, agency execution still involves the client's mandate, a transparent execution policy and clear fees and commissions. Avoiding market risk on an order does not eliminate operational work or responsibility for carrying out that mandate.
For principal dealing, the important questions include when market risk transfers, what being the customer's counterparty entails and whether risk management is proportionate to the exposure assumed. Consider a customer price fixed before the upstream conversion is executed: the interval between those events can matter economically. The agreed pricing and trade terms determine whether, and for how long, your business carries that exposure.
Promptly offsetting a trade may reduce market exposure, but it does not by itself resolve credit, settlement or customer-obligation questions. The external provider is part of the operating arrangement, not proof that every responsibility has moved outside your business.
This is where the partnership decision becomes more than a commission negotiation. A lower-share referral offer can be the better business if it produces dependable income with work you can serve efficiently. A customer-facing arrangement can be worth more if the control has a clear commercial use and your team can manage the obligations attached to it. Principal status alone promises neither better margins nor a better customer proposition.
Conclusion
The strongest FX partnership is not necessarily the one with the largest advertised share or the most outsourced execution. It is the one where the calculation base, your own costs, cash timing and customer obligations form a workable business. Compare what remains in your hands with what remains on your shoulders.
For requesting more information about how we can help reach out to us. We're here to help and answer any questions you may have.