Anchoring and adjustment is a judgment heuristic in which a person forms an estimate by starting from a reference value, or anchor, and revising it in light of other information. The starting value may be useful, misleading or unrelated to the question. The process can distort an estimate when the anchor retains more influence than the available evidence warrants.
How the Process Works
An anchor provides an initial answer to a question such as what something is worth or how long a task will take. Anchors can be self-generated, such as a remembered price, or externally supplied, such as an asking price. They need not be consciously or deliberately selected. A number encountered incidentally can sometimes influence an estimate even when it has no relevant connection to the task.
In anchoring and adjustment, other information prompts revision upward or downward from that starting point. In a hypothetical purchase, a buyer might begin with the seller's asking price and lower their estimate after noticing wear. The asking price is relevant to the transaction, but it is not necessarily reliable evidence of value. Comparable sales might support a substantially different estimate.
Why Adjustment Can Be Insufficient
Revision may stop when an estimate seems plausible rather than when it adequately reflects the evidence. A person can therefore move away from an anchor while still remaining too close to it. Otherwise comparable people exposed to high and low anchors may reach different estimates of the same quantity, even when they have access to the same relevant information.
This is the central risk associated with anchoring and adjustment: making a correction does not establish that the correction was sufficient. The pathway from an arbitrary number to insufficient adjustment and a biased judgment is possible, not inevitable. An irrelevant anchor may have little effect, and an anchored estimate is not necessarily inaccurate in every instance.
Looking for liquidity, exploring on-ramp/off-ramp services, or seeking expert guidance?
Get startedWhat Makes Anchoring a Bias
Anchoring bias is the undue influence of a reference point on a judgment. Anchoring and adjustment describes an estimation process; using that process is not inherently an error. A relevant starting value, appropriately revised, can be a reasonable basis for an estimate. The important question is whether the final judgment reflects the evidence rather than an unjustified attachment to the starting point.
Insufficient adjustment is not the only explanation for anchoring effects. An anchor can also make information consistent with it easier to bring to mind, influencing which evidence receives attention. Observing that a number influenced an answer does not, by itself, prove that someone mentally started at that number and then revised it.
Evaluating a Starting Value
A useful precaution is to form an independent estimate before considering a suggested value, where practical. Relevant benchmarks can help test whether a remembered price, opening offer or previous forecast deserves weight. Those benchmarks should be appropriate to the specific question, rather than simply providing another convenient number. Another precaution is to consider conflicting evidence and ask what would justify a substantially higher or lower estimate.
These steps are precautions, not guaranteed ways to eliminate bias. Awareness of anchoring and adjustment does not ensure that a person will revise enough or identify every influence on their judgment. The aim is to assess the starting value and the evidence supporting the final estimate, not merely to move away from an anchor for its own sake.